« I've Been Tagged By Scot McKnight | Main | God Works in Difficult Places (Mothers #1) »

Comments

Meredith

Good thoughts......

Erin

Father figures are so important-- and it's so sad that so many children are growing without a daddy. Thanks for bringing up this important topic.

Mike

I just finished "Dragon" this morning and plan to use it in my counseling and discipleship. I liked this even more than "Blue Like Jazz."

I'm sure it comes as no surprise to you that I deal with sons of absent or neglectful and/or abusive fathers all the time. It was interesting, too, to see the difference in effects between the absence of a father (as with Miller) and the presence of a bad father (as with me). There are probably more similarities than differences, but the differences are significant. Perhaps I'll post on it sometime when I can afford to reflect on it more.

There is so, so much in the book, but you have provided an accurate taste for anyone who might be wondering if they should read it or not. I would suggest all pastors read it: most of the men in your church, on your deacon board, and/or your elder board likely have issues addressed in this book.

kent

This is a powerful topic which I have been thinking about a lot these days. I have three sons whom I love and are proud of. I am often aggrivated at them too, but that goes with the territory. I have been to their games, taken them on driving vacations, have tried love their mother as best I am able, have cared for them when they were sick and was never afraid of their diapers. I have said yes about as often I have said no. They would tell you differently, but there you go. I have put one through college and will so do the same with the others.

But in the back of your mind you wonder if it has been enough. If you read the authors on parenthood from the sources we have held as authorities the answer would be no. That there was I have been told more expected and to be honest I didn't deliver. My elequence about my feelings for them has often fallen short. I have been angry and said things that they may remember with pain. I probably cannot tell you all the names of their friends, and I do not hand out money liberally. I have expected that they will help out around the house and that they pick up after themselves. I have never felt the need to be their very best friend. That is not my role. And to be honest I do not have guilt.

I fear our expectations of Dad's and Father's have exceed what is possible. We are sinners, and we do make many many mistakes. Our models from previous generations have been flawed, and time is always short. I read through the Bible for models and I don't find any in Abraham or Jacob or David. So I pray and I try not exasperate my sons more than necessary. Just as I have forgiven my Dad, he did the best he could, I pray my sons will forgive me. I think they will, they too will have children one day.

Mike

The thing about parenting - and, in this case, fathering - is that one only has to be "good enough," which is actually not all that difficult if the father is present, emotional available, and actively engaged in his son's life. A father who was always there would actually being doing a disservice to his son.

When a father is present and engaged, the son learns of the fallibility and failings of his father, but because it happens over time and in the context of overall good fathering, it is not traumatic. The son learns to love a less-than-perfect father and comes to have realistic expectations of himself and others.

When a father is absent, negligent, or abusive, however, the ideal father figure in the boy's brain remains. This often leads to the unrealistic expectations that sons/men have of fathers and those in positions of authority. Therein lies a part of the problem: there is either a deep resentment coupled with an unrealistic notion of what fathers are supposed to be like, or there is a deep sense of unloveability and an unrealistic idea of what fathers are supposed to be.

Good fathers with good relationships don't have to worry about sons growing up with a distorted view of fathers. But sons without fathers are left to guess at what a father is supposed to do or be.

Jim Martin

Mike,
Thanks for both comments. Your words regarding the impact of an absent or poor father are very insightful.

I especially read with interest your comments regarding the "ideal father" image. Helpful.

Thanks also for the idea of getting guys in the churches to read this book. That is such a good idea.

Jim Martin

Kent,
I think you are on to something very important. I do think a lot of guys have some very unreal expectations for themselves. You express it well.

Then---on the other side are the guys who do not seem to realize that it is time to grow up and be Dads.

I think I have seen both groups in the church.

Ted Gossard

Thanks Jim.

I wish I would have known so much when I was younger. There is so much parents need to give to their children. Not only wisdom, but as part of that wisdom the confidence to try.

Thanks for sharing on the book. I'll have to read it.

The comments to this entry are closed.

My Photo

Newsvine Sports News

September 2006

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
          1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30

Some Things That Interest Me

Typepad